U.S. Supreme Court Victory for College Athletes in NCAA Scholarship Antitrust Class-Action Lawsuit
Posted on Jun 25, 2021 6:20pm PDT
On Monday June 21, 2021, the Supreme Court of the United States upheld
lower court rulings that the National Collegiate Athletic Association’s
restrictions on education-related benefits violated federal antitrust
law. The Supreme Court’s 9-0 decision brings an end to more than
7 years of hard-fought litigation led by Pearson, Simon & Warshaw,
LLP and co-counsel Winston & Strawn, LLP and Hagens Berman Sobol Shapiro
LLP. The defendants in the case were the NCAA and the top athletic conferences
in the country, who were represented by some of the most prestigious defense
law firms in the country.
“This is a banner day for college athletes,” said Pearson,
Simon & Warshaw attorney Ben Shiftan. “For far too long, college
athletes have put their blood, sweat, and tears into their sports, earning
enormous sums of money for their universities and the NCAA, all while
having their educational benefits artificially capped. The fact that the
Supreme Court ruled 9-0 makes it all the more special.”
The decision pokes significant holes in the NCAA’s mantra that it
should be permitted to cap compensation to college athletes in the name
of “amateurism.” As Justice Gorsuch noted in the majority
opinion, “the district court found that the NCAA had not adopted
any consistent definition” of amateurism and that “[i]nstead,
the court found, the NCAA's rules and restrictions on compensation
have shifted markedly over time.” As Justice Kavanaugh noted in
his concurrence, the NCAA should not be permitted to cap compensation
under the theory that “the defining feature of college sports .
. . is that the student athletes are not paid.” After all, “[a]ll
of the restaurants in a region cannot come together to cut cooks’
wages on the theory that ‘customers prefer’ to eat food from
low-paid cooks. Law firms cannot conspire to cabin lawyers’ salaries
in the name of providing legal services out of a ‘love of the law.’
Hospitals cannot agree to cap nurses’ income in order to create
a ‘purer’ form of helping the sick.”
The decision will be cited by courts throughout the country for decades
to come. However, it is just one part of the nationwide movement to improve
college athletes’ economic rights. Pearson, Simon & Warshaw
looks forward to continuing the fight on behalf of college athletes.